When Terry Brooks published The Sword of Shannara, I was one of the first kids to dive straight into it. And even at that early age (I was in junior high school at the time) I remember being shocked at how much it followed Tolkien's Lord of the Rings point-by-point. In LOTR you had the nine ringwraiths...in Brooks you had the nine skullbearers, in LOTR you had Sauron, in Brooks you had the Warlock Lord, and it goes on and on. The King of the Silver River is Elrond, the Hall of Kings is Moria complete with monster at the gate, and the druids are simply the Istari wizards. The Druids Keep is Isengard and Allanon is Gandalf, etc. You even have two hobbits...only they aren't called hobbits but they are from Shady Vale...a place a lot like Hobbiton. And their names are Flint and Shea instead of Frodo and Sam. Anyway...this is a well documented thing...the fact that a New York Times bestselling author blatantly stole from the grandfather of all epic fantasy and in the end...no one gave a shit. And to Brooks' credit, it didn't stop me from reading his books. I was hungry for fantasy at the time so I bought all the Shannara books as they came out and they steadily got better and better (and more original). I thought Elfstones of Shannara was awesome so yeah...he forged himself a great writing career. However, just out of the gate (so to speak) I thought things were so shameless with his first book that I would have been downright embarrassed had anyone called me on it.
Anyway, this is happening again in a book I'm reading. What book you ask? It's Amanda Hocking's Trylle trilogy and the first book is called Switched. Don't get me wrong...Amanda is a wonderful writer. I enjoy her prose but the woman doesn't have a story. No, she has Stephanie Meyer's story. Things started smacking me over the head about Chapter Six. Let me see if you can pick what book she is following point-by-point as I lay them out for you.
We are introduced to the female protagonist named Wendy. She considers herself unattractive, her hair is awful, and she has no friends. She's the new girl in a high school in a small town and awkward as hell. One day, a gorgeous boy starts staring at her and continues to do so until it makes her so uncomfortable she can't stand it. When she asks him about it...he is evasive...won't give her a straight answer. Only later on does she discover that he's a Trylle...the word for troll...and that he has essentially super powers. And he's very long-lived. Oh and he visits her in her bedroom at night...does this scene sound familiar?
One night outside her home, her life is threatened. Not with a careening car but setup almost the same. Two people attack her and "Finn" the hot dude saves her all by himself (pushing the bad people away). Then he takes her to his home which is absolutely gorgeous to meet his family of other trolls who are Gucci and Prada wearing, sushi-eating, upper class snobs. I mean super rich. Like millionaire rich (high society). And it's secluded in the woods (think evergreen forests) with a view of the Mississippi River... Instead of a black Volvo we have a black Porsche. She also finds out that there's something inherent in her that makes Finn stare at her. He can smell her. It's her hair (not blood) and it's irresistible to other Trylle.
That's all the farther I've gotten...but does that sound familiar to you? Does that point-by-point sound like a certain highly successful New York Times bestseller?
I know that some of you writers out there always say, "There are no original ideas." But COME ON! for Pete's sake!?
I mean, is there any shame to this? Here...let me give you an example of what I mean...
Hey author friends! Here's my AMAZING plot for my story...OMG...IT'S SO GOOD AND I WILL MAKE MILLIONS. I even have cover art for it already made...check it out:
Dude from a future where mankind is pushed to extinction by machines escapes through a portal into the past. He's on a mission to save a woman targeted by the machines of the future. He has to stop a killer robot only, along the way, he falls in love with the woman and they have sex and she gets pregnant. Here's the hitch...her baby will someday be this guy's father.
Holy shit! Isn't that great?! I iz so smart this is sure to be a bestseller and you all will be jealous while I'm making millions.
Anyway...what do you guys think? Amanda's books are huge bestsellers (maybe not as big as Twilight) but they've made her rich. Terry Brooks is a rich fat cat too and he blatantly copied Tolkien. I'm wondering why someone isn't blatantly copying J.K. Rowling. I mean you could do it and self-pub and probably catch a portion of the same audience that J.K. has. Even at 1% that's 4 million people that are going to buy your books. How would you like to sell 4 million books?
Oh ummm...here's my story...there's this paranormal school that teacheswizards ghosts, vamps, werewolf kids how to properly use their powers. Each one has a wand fetish like a silver bullet or locket that they channel their magic through. There are professors in the school. One paranormal boy named Charles Hatter is the only kid that survived when dark wizards ghosts, vamps, and werewolves led by Voldemort a real powerful dude attacked the family and left a mark on his forehead eyes (his eyes have flickering lightning bolts in the irises).
And to any of you that would say "You can get sued for this kind of copycat behavior"...I don't think that you can. Maybe Mr. Pagel can weigh in on this because he's a lawyer. But I'm pretty sure that ideas cannot be copyrighted...meaning a general idea...like a plot.
Anyway...authors that do this have no shame. I'm actually kind of disgusted. But they are richer than me and have huge publishing contracts so does what I think really matter? Nope.
How the hell did publishing get to be so terrible? Is it money? Are people so hard up to make a buck that they clone what other writers come up with and pass it off as their own story? Does it ever occur to people that if they are just blatantly going to steal a novel point-for-point, chapter-by-chapter and just change names and setting that...I dunno...maybe the world doesn't need another book like this? I guess I'm old school. Writing isn't just about writing for me. It's storytelling. And please don't tell me a story I've already heard. I don't want to read George R.R. Martin's story as told by John Doe with all the names changed and have to put up with all the praise you get lauded because the idiots out there who read books aren't well read enough to know that a story is a ripoff.
Anyway, this is happening again in a book I'm reading. What book you ask? It's Amanda Hocking's Trylle trilogy and the first book is called Switched. Don't get me wrong...Amanda is a wonderful writer. I enjoy her prose but the woman doesn't have a story. No, she has Stephanie Meyer's story. Things started smacking me over the head about Chapter Six. Let me see if you can pick what book she is following point-by-point as I lay them out for you.
 |
| These two books are essentially the same story. Only names have been changed. |
One night outside her home, her life is threatened. Not with a careening car but setup almost the same. Two people attack her and "Finn" the hot dude saves her all by himself (pushing the bad people away). Then he takes her to his home which is absolutely gorgeous to meet his family of other trolls who are Gucci and Prada wearing, sushi-eating, upper class snobs. I mean super rich. Like millionaire rich (high society). And it's secluded in the woods (think evergreen forests) with a view of the Mississippi River... Instead of a black Volvo we have a black Porsche. She also finds out that there's something inherent in her that makes Finn stare at her. He can smell her. It's her hair (not blood) and it's irresistible to other Trylle.
That's all the farther I've gotten...but does that sound familiar to you? Does that point-by-point sound like a certain highly successful New York Times bestseller?
I know that some of you writers out there always say, "There are no original ideas." But COME ON! for Pete's sake!?
I mean, is there any shame to this? Here...let me give you an example of what I mean...
Hey author friends! Here's my AMAZING plot for my story...OMG...IT'S SO GOOD AND I WILL MAKE MILLIONS. I even have cover art for it already made...check it out:
Dude from a future where mankind is pushed to extinction by machines escapes through a portal into the past. He's on a mission to save a woman targeted by the machines of the future. He has to stop a killer robot only, along the way, he falls in love with the woman and they have sex and she gets pregnant. Here's the hitch...her baby will someday be this guy's father.
Holy shit! Isn't that great?! I iz so smart this is sure to be a bestseller and you all will be jealous while I'm making millions.
Anyway...what do you guys think? Amanda's books are huge bestsellers (maybe not as big as Twilight) but they've made her rich. Terry Brooks is a rich fat cat too and he blatantly copied Tolkien. I'm wondering why someone isn't blatantly copying J.K. Rowling. I mean you could do it and self-pub and probably catch a portion of the same audience that J.K. has. Even at 1% that's 4 million people that are going to buy your books. How would you like to sell 4 million books?
Oh ummm...here's my story...there's this paranormal school that teaches
And to any of you that would say "You can get sued for this kind of copycat behavior"...I don't think that you can. Maybe Mr. Pagel can weigh in on this because he's a lawyer. But I'm pretty sure that ideas cannot be copyrighted...meaning a general idea...like a plot.
Anyway...authors that do this have no shame. I'm actually kind of disgusted. But they are richer than me and have huge publishing contracts so does what I think really matter? Nope.
How the hell did publishing get to be so terrible? Is it money? Are people so hard up to make a buck that they clone what other writers come up with and pass it off as their own story? Does it ever occur to people that if they are just blatantly going to steal a novel point-for-point, chapter-by-chapter and just change names and setting that...I dunno...maybe the world doesn't need another book like this? I guess I'm old school. Writing isn't just about writing for me. It's storytelling. And please don't tell me a story I've already heard. I don't want to read George R.R. Martin's story as told by John Doe with all the names changed and have to put up with all the praise you get lauded because the idiots out there who read books aren't well read enough to know that a story is a ripoff.
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar